Who’s Leading Who? Guide Dogs, Stereotypes, and Joy

When I started working at National Braille Press almost ten years ago, I had very little knowledge about braille or the blindness community. I was drawn to NBP because I love to read and was shocked that there was so little material available in braille. NBP’s mission was a social justice issue for me.

But I worried a bit about how best to convey that message.  I wanted to get the tone right and not pander to stereotypes that may raise money but do NOT raise awareness.

Liooking Out for SarahThen I read a speech that Diane Croft had given at the Guide Dog Users of Massachusetts Award Dinner on a print/braille book NBP produced called Looking Out for Sarah. The speech was addressed to Glenna Lang, the author, and her guide dog.  It resonated with me and changed my thinking forever.

Here is an excerpt of what Diane wrote:

I have lived through three movements: civil rights, women’s rights, and disability rights.  In all three cases much has changed and much remains the same.

And so, when a children’s book on blindness crosses my desk, I brace myself. Even after 20* years in the field, I am astonished to see the same age-old stereotypes that permeate our society reflected, either subtly or profoundly, within the images and text of a book. To be honest, when I saw the title Looking Out for Sarah, I wondered if this would be another book where someone “looks after” a blind adult.

But then I read the opening sentence: “In the early morning light…”

I assume you know with those five words you broke through one of the oldest and most deeply entrenched stereotypes–namely, that blind people live in the dark.

The book continues:

“Perry felt Sarah stirring about him…he waited eagerly for her feet to touch the floor.”

The reader feels an immediate sense of anticipation and even joy at the start of a new day. For the most part, sighted people do no equate blindness with joy.

Throughout the book, the question of who is looking after whom fluctuates between Sarah and Perry. How wonderful you didn’t err in either direction. Perry looks out for overhanging branches, but it’s Sarah who initiates their adventuresome cross-country journey.

Your important book addresses core relationship issues of dependency and independence, of submission and initiation. Sarah and Perry both initiate and give up control to each other depending on the situation.

Your beautiful book shows that in all healthy, joyful relationships, there is a constant sharing and shifting–back and forth–between who needs whom, who takes care of whom, and how we love one another.

*Diane Croft, Publisher at NBP, has worked at National Braille Press for over 30 years.

4 thoughts on “Who’s Leading Who? Guide Dogs, Stereotypes, and Joy

  1. What a great post/article! Thank you so much for sharing. This is particularly meaningful to me for many reasons. First, I work at a school for the blind, where braille literacy is huge for our students, second, I love the book “Looking Out for Sarah” because of the positive message it delivers (as you stated in your article). I am a COMS and this was the first book I ever purchased in print/braille format to share with my students. Third, it’s safe to say I’m a long time fan of NBP for everything your organization does to empower students/individuals who have visual impairments. And on a personal note, I am a big supporter of Guiding Eyes for the Blind (where Sarah’s guide dog is from) as my husband is a Guiding Eyes graduate and we raised a puppy for Guiding Eyes who recently became a guide in your wonderful town of Boston. Thank you NBP, I will share this great article with my fellow co-workers who are also very appreciative of your organization.

      • Hi Taryn! Thanks for the reply. A COMS is a Certified Orientation and Mobility Specialist. We teach persons with visual impairments travel strategies so that they can more effectively and safely access the world/community around them. O&M (orientation and mobility) is an essential need when striving to get a dog guide. Plus, I think it is one of the coolest jobs in the world to have!!

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s